Class
Senior
Graduated
After the 2025 season, Indiana
Mitch McCarthy is a 6'5", 230-lb Senior P at Indiana from Melbourne, VIC.
Updated Oct 26, 2026
Get portal alerts for Indiana
An email when a Indiana player enters the portal, commits, or withdraws. Free.
Advanced Statistics
2025 · 11 puntsGross Average
39.5 yds
14th
Net Average
38.5 yds
38th
Inside 20 Rate
36.4%
47th
Touchback Rate
0.0%
85th
Return Rate
36.4%
15th
Fair Catch Rate
27.3%
57th
Percentiles rank this season against every 2025 FBS and FCS punters with the same minimum sample. Higher is better; for touchback and return rates, fewer is better.
TVS History
Before past portal windows
| Window | Team | TVS | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | Indiana | 15 Moderate | Did not enter |
| 2025 | UCF | 11 Low | Entered portal |
| 2024 | UCF | 6 Low | Did not enter |
Each score comes from a model trained only on seasons before that roster year, so it shows what TVS would have said at the time.
Season Statistics
| Season | Team | Punts | Gross Avg | Net Avg |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | Indiana | 11 | 39.5 | 38.5 |
Most Likely to Leave Indiana
Khobie MartinRB · Indiana
Lebron BondWR · Indiana
Myles KendrickWR · Indiana
Jacob BellQB · Indiana
Zacharey SmithDB · Indiana
Nico RadicicPK · IndianaSimilar P Players
