TransferPortl

Roster Talent Index

How much talent each FBS roster held before the 2022 season,from last season's production, transfers and recruits. The index is a roster's chance to beat an average FBS roster on a neutral field. Expected wins apply it to the real schedule, so wins above or below expected show which coaches get more or less out of their roster.

Most wins above talent

  1. James Madison8-3, 1.9 exp +6.1
  2. Duke9-4, 4.0 exp +5.0
  3. TCU13-2, 8.4 exp +4.5
  4. Kansas State10-4, 5.6 exp +4.4
  5. Ohio10-4, 5.8 exp +4.3

Most wins below talent

  1. Colorado State3-9, 7.3 exp −4.3
  2. South Florida1-11, 5.2 exp −4.2
  3. Northern Illinois3-9, 7.1 exp −4.1
  4. Massachusetts1-11, 5.0 exp −4.0
  5. Northwestern1-11, 4.9 exp −3.9

2022 FBS Rosters

RkTeamIndexRecordExp. W+/−
1Ohio State8811-210.4+0.6
2Alabama8611-210.0+1.0
3Texas868-510.4−2.4
4Georgia8515-011.3+3.6
5Notre Dame839-49.7−0.7
6Texas A&M815-78.7−3.7
7Arkansas817-68.8−1.8
8Clemson7711-39.6+1.4
9Oklahoma776-79.7−3.6
10Florida State7710-38.6+1.4
11Tennessee7711-28.1+2.9
12Kentucky767-68.7−1.7
13Penn State7411-28.2+2.8
14LSU7410-48.4+1.6
15Miami735-78.2−3.2
16Pittsburgh719-49.0+0.0
17Michigan7113-19.0+4.0
18Michigan State705-77.8−2.8
19Wake Forest708-58.5−0.5
20USC6911-38.9+2.0
21Oregon6810-38.3+1.7
22Auburn685-76.2−1.2
23North Carolina679-58.2+0.8
24Wisconsin677-67.9−0.9
25Iowa668-58.1−0.1
26Purdue658-68.3−0.3
27Utah6510-48.9+1.1
28Ole Miss648-57.0+1.0
29UCF629-59.6−0.6
30TCU6213-28.4+4.5
31Louisville618-56.7+1.3
32NC State618-57.8+0.2
33SMU617-68.0−1.0
34South Carolina608-56.3+1.7
35Cincinnati589-48.1+0.9
36UTSA5811-39.1+1.9
37Boise State5810-49.4+0.6
38Washington5711-27.3+3.8
39Houston578-57.6+0.4
40Nebraska574-86.5−2.5
41Stanford573-96.4−3.4
42BYU578-57.3+0.7
43Florida576-76.4−0.4
44Memphis567-67.7−0.7
45Texas Tech568-56.7+1.3
46Maryland568-56.3+1.7
47Fresno State5510-49.1+0.9
48Minnesota559-47.1+1.9
49Georgia State554-87.5−3.5
50Kansas556-76.7−0.7
51Western Kentucky549-59.1−0.1
52East Carolina548-57.8+0.2
53Missouri546-76.3−0.3
54Virginia543-75.4−2.4
55Mississippi State539-45.7+3.3
56Oklahoma State537-66.5+0.5
57Arizona State533-96.6−3.6
58Tulane5312-27.8+4.2
59Army536-67.3−1.3
60App State536-66.6−0.6
61Miami (OH)536-77.0−1.0
62Illinois538-55.8+2.2
63Troy5312-27.8+4.2
64UCLA529-46.7+2.3
65Boston College523-95.5−2.5
66Old Dominion523-96.6−3.6
67Oregon State5210-36.7+3.3
68Virginia Tech523-85.7−2.7
69Arizona515-75.8−0.8
70Georgia Southern516-77.3−1.3
71South Florida511-115.2−4.2
72Air Force5010-37.7+2.3
73Toledo509-58.3+0.7
74Bowling Green506-77.7−1.7
75Colorado State503-97.3−4.3
76Northern Illinois503-97.1−4.1
77Georgia Tech495-74.0+1.0
78Kent State495-76.0−1.0
79Coastal Carolina499-47.3+1.7
80Charlotte493-96.3−3.3
81San Diego State487-68.0−1.0
82Baylor486-76.3−0.3
83Rice485-86.3−1.3
84Marshall489-47.3+1.7
85Northwestern471-114.9−3.9
86Utah State476-77.3−1.3
87San José State477-56.9+0.1
88South Alabama4710-36.7+3.3
89California464-85.5−1.4
90Eastern Michigan469-47.3+1.7
91Liberty468-57.0+1.1
92UTEP465-75.6−0.6
93Tulsa465-75.9−0.9
94Syracuse467-65.0+2.0
95UAB457-66.1+0.9
96Middle Tennessee458-56.3+1.7
97Rutgers454-84.8−0.8
98Akron442-105.4−3.4
99Kansas State4410-45.6+4.4
100Florida Atlantic445-75.8−0.8
101Indiana444-84.1−0.1
102North Texas447-76.3+0.7
103Texas State444-86.8−2.8
104West Virginia445-74.3+0.7
105Arkansas State433-95.8−2.8
106Louisiana436-76.7−0.7
107Central Michigan424-85.5−1.4
108Colorado421-113.9−2.9
109Vanderbilt425-74.0+1.0
110Southern Miss417-65.7+1.3
111Iowa State414-84.8−0.8
112UConn406-75.1+0.9
113UL Monroe404-84.6−0.6
114Buffalo407-65.8+1.2
115Washington State407-64.8+2.2
116Louisiana Tech393-95.2−2.2
117New Mexico State397-66.4+0.6
118Florida International384-85.4−1.4
119Ball State375-74.9+0.1
120Massachusetts361-115.0−4.0
121Temple363-94.6−1.6
122Ohio3410-45.8+4.3
123UNLV335-75.1−0.1
124Western Michigan335-74.6+0.4
125Nevada322-104.6−2.6
126Duke329-44.0+5.0
127Wyoming317-65.0+2.0
128New Mexico292-104.2−2.2
129Navy284-83.4+0.6
130Hawai'i183-103.2−0.2
131James Madison158-31.9+6.1
132Sam Houston145-44.7+0.3
133Jacksonville State119-25.2+3.9
134Missouri State115-66.3−1.3
135Kennesaw State115-64.5+0.5
136Delaware108-56.3+1.8
How the index works

Each player gets a talent score from what was known before the season: last season's production and efficiency, adjusted for the level of his team, plus his recruiting rating while he is young. Transfers bring their production with them. A model trained on every FBS game since 2021 learns how much each position group is worth.

The model never sees the coach or last season's record, so wins above or below expected measure what a staff does with its roster. Past seasons are scored by a model that did not train on them. In one season, about half of the gap is luck in close games; over several seasons, the coach's share shows.

Service academies get an adjustment because their rosters have few rated recruits. BYU's rosters, with many players back from missions, are also harder to rate.