TransferPortl

Roster Talent Index

How much talent each FBS roster held before the 2023 season,from last season's production, transfers and recruits. The index is a roster's chance to beat an average FBS roster on a neutral field. Expected wins apply it to the real schedule, so wins above or below expected show which coaches get more or less out of their roster.

Most wins above talent

  1. Jacksonville State9-4, 2.7 exp +6.3
  2. Liberty13-1, 7.8 exp +5.2
  3. James Madison11-2, 6.6 exp +4.4
  4. Oklahoma State10-4, 5.8 exp +4.2
  5. Michigan15-0, 10.9 exp +4.1

Most wins below talent

  1. Baylor3-9, 7.0 exp −4.0
  2. Akron2-10, 5.9 exp −3.9
  3. Temple3-9, 6.7 exp −3.6
  4. UConn3-9, 6.6 exp −3.6
  5. Florida Atlantic4-8, 7.3 exp −3.4

2023 FBS Rosters

RkTeamIndexRecordExp. W+/−
1Ohio State8511-29.8+1.2
2Alabama8412-29.9+2.1
3Georgia8313-110.4+2.6
4LSU8310-38.8+1.2
5Oregon8112-210.4+1.6
6Michigan8015-010.9+4.1
7Texas A&M797-68.8−1.8
8Florida State7913-19.8+3.2
9Ole Miss7811-28.2+2.8
10Tennessee789-48.2+0.8
11Clemson789-49.4−0.5
12Penn State7810-39.5+0.5
13Texas7712-210.2+1.8
14Notre Dame7610-39.7+0.3
15Washington7614-19.9+4.1
16USC768-59.1−1.1
17Arkansas754-87.3−3.3
18Utah748-58.8−0.8
19Oklahoma7310-39.8+0.2
20Auburn736-77.2−1.2
21North Carolina708-58.9−0.9
22Wisconsin707-68.8−1.8
23Missouri6911-27.4+3.6
24Florida685-76.4−1.4
25South Carolina685-76.8−1.8
26Texas Tech647-67.3−0.3
27Kansas639-48.1+0.9
28Miami637-67.7−0.7
29UCLA628-58.0−0.0
30Baylor613-97.0−4.0
31Maryland618-58.0−0.0
32Duke618-57.0+1.0
33Mississippi State615-76.1−1.1
34Louisville5910-48.2+1.8
35South Alabama597-69.1−2.1
36Kentucky597-66.5+0.5
37West Virginia589-45.9+3.1
38UTSA589-48.0+1.1
39Arizona State583-95.9−2.9
40Minnesota586-76.8−0.8
41Pittsburgh573-96.0−3.0
42BYU565-76.3−1.3
43Ohio5610-38.9+1.1
44UCF566-77.8−1.8
45Arizona5610-36.6+3.4
46Michigan State564-85.9−1.9
47Toledo5611-39.5+1.5
48NC State569-46.4+2.6
49Virginia Tech557-66.7+0.3
50Oregon State548-56.0+2.0
51Wake Forest544-85.7−1.6
52Temple543-96.7−3.6
53Marshall546-77.1−1.1
54SMU5411-39.1+1.9
55Houston534-86.1−2.1
56Rutgers537-65.5+1.5
57TCU535-76.6−1.6
58Tulane5311-38.3+2.7
59Iowa State537-65.0+2.0
60Illinois535-75.4−0.4
61Georgia Southern526-77.6−1.6
62Northwestern528-55.3+2.7
63Florida Atlantic524-87.3−3.4
64Wyoming529-47.2+1.8
65Bowling Green517-67.0+0.1
66Memphis5110-37.3+2.7
67UNLV519-57.5+1.5
68Cincinnati513-96.0−3.0
69Kansas State519-45.3+3.6
70Colorado State515-76.9−1.9
71Boise State508-67.5+0.5
72Coastal Carolina508-57.9+0.1
73San José State507-66.4+0.6
74New Mexico State5010-59.1+0.9
75Miami (OH)5011-37.4+3.6
76Syracuse496-76.2−0.2
77Nebraska495-75.0−0.1
78Washington State495-75.2−0.2
79UConn493-96.6−3.6
80Boston College497-66.5+0.5
81Virginia493-94.3−1.3
82Oklahoma State4810-45.8+4.2
83Troy4811-38.6+2.4
84Eastern Michigan486-77.6−1.6
85Stanford483-94.0−1.0
86Navy475-76.1−1.1
87Purdue474-85.3−1.4
88UAB474-85.0−0.9
89California476-75.7+0.3
90North Texas475-75.9−0.9
91Western Kentucky478-58.0−0.0
92Georgia State477-66.3+0.7
93App State479-56.8+2.2
94Liberty4713-17.8+5.2
95Georgia Tech467-65.2+1.8
96James Madison4611-26.6+4.4
97Rice466-76.2−0.2
98Colorado464-84.7−0.7
99San Diego State464-86.5−2.5
100Indiana453-94.3−1.3
101South Florida457-65.9+1.1
102Fresno State459-47.2+1.8
103Iowa4510-46.6+3.4
104Louisiana456-77.0−1.1
105Florida International444-86.9−2.9
106Middle Tennessee434-86.3−2.3
107Southern Miss433-95.5−2.5
108Air Force439-47.3+1.8
109Army426-66.0+0.0
110Vanderbilt422-104.0−2.0
111Hawai'i415-86.0−1.0
112East Carolina412-104.7−2.7
113Massachusetts403-95.1−2.1
114Central Michigan405-74.9+0.1
115Louisiana Tech403-96.3−3.3
116Akron392-105.9−3.9
117Arkansas State386-76.0−0.1
118Texas State378-55.7+2.3
119Ball State364-85.0−1.0
120Old Dominion356-75.1+0.9
121Northern Illinois357-66.2+0.8
122Charlotte343-94.6−1.6
123Nevada322-104.6−2.6
124Utah State326-75.0+0.9
125Buffalo303-94.7−1.7
126Western Michigan304-84.1−0.1
127New Mexico304-84.1−0.1
128Tulsa304-83.8+0.2
129UTEP283-95.0−2.0
130Kent State271-113.5−2.5
131UL Monroe252-103.4−1.4
132Jacksonville State179-42.7+6.3
133Sam Houston153-92.6+0.4
134Delaware129-46.3+2.7
135Missouri State124-74.6−0.6
136Kennesaw State102-64.0−2.0
How the index works

Each player gets a talent score from what was known before the season: last season's production and efficiency, adjusted for the level of his team, plus his recruiting rating while he is young. Transfers bring their production with them. A model trained on every FBS game since 2021 learns how much each position group is worth.

The model never sees the coach or last season's record, so wins above or below expected measure what a staff does with its roster. Past seasons are scored by a model that did not train on them. In one season, about half of the gap is luck in close games; over several seasons, the coach's share shows.

Service academies get an adjustment because their rosters have few rated recruits. BYU's rosters, with many players back from missions, are also harder to rate.