TransferPortl

Roster Talent Index

How much talent each FBS roster held before the 2024 season,from last season's production, transfers and recruits. The index is a roster's chance to beat an average FBS roster on a neutral field. Expected wins apply it to the real schedule, so wins above or below expected show which coaches get more or less out of their roster.

Most wins above talent

  1. Army12-2, 5.2 exp +6.8
  2. BYU11-2, 4.5 exp +6.5
  3. Arizona State11-3, 5.2 exp +5.8
  4. Navy10-3, 4.7 exp +5.3
  5. Illinois10-3, 5.0 exp +5.0

Most wins below talent

  1. Florida State2-10, 7.3 exp −5.3
  2. Kent State0-12, 4.5 exp −4.5
  3. UAB3-9, 6.7 exp −3.7
  4. Arizona4-8, 7.7 exp −3.7
  5. Southern Miss1-11, 4.7 exp −3.6

2024 FBS Rosters

RkTeamIndexRecordExp. W+/−
1Texas A&M878-59.2−1.2
2Texas8513-311.7+1.3
3Oregon8513-110.9+2.1
4Georgia8411-39.6+1.4
5Ohio State8314-211.5+2.5
6Notre Dame8314-211.9+2.1
7Ole Miss8210-39.0+1.0
8Florida828-57.7+0.3
9Oklahoma806-78.9−3.0
10Florida State792-107.3−5.3
11LSU799-48.5+0.5
12Penn State7913-311.1+1.9
13SMU7911-39.5+1.5
14Miami7910-38.6+1.4
15Auburn785-77.3−2.3
16Alabama779-48.0+1.0
17Wisconsin775-77.8−2.8
18USC767-67.6−0.6
19Missouri7610-38.2+1.8
20South Carolina769-48.3+0.8
21Clemson7510-48.5+1.5
22Tennessee7310-38.0+2.0
23Michigan738-57.9+0.1
24TCU739-48.5+0.5
25Arizona734-87.7−3.7
26UCF724-87.5−3.5
27Indiana7011-27.8+3.3
28California696-78.4−2.4
29Utah695-77.5−2.5
30Virginia Tech696-78.2−2.2
31Iowa State6911-38.3+2.6
32Texas Tech688-58.00.0
33Louisville679-47.6+1.4
34Michigan State665-76.9−1.9
35Nebraska647-67.5−0.5
36App State645-68.0−3.0
37Kansas635-77.4−2.4
38Kansas State639-47.7+1.3
39Georgia Tech627-66.1+0.9
40Colorado629-47.3+1.7
41Memphis6211-29.0+2.0
42Arkansas617-66.5+0.5
43UCLA615-76.1−1.1
44NC State606-78.1−2.1
45Iowa608-56.8+1.2
46Kentucky604-85.7−1.7
47Oklahoma State593-96.5−3.5
48West Virginia596-77.0−1.0
49Boston College597-65.9+1.1
50Baylor588-56.7+1.3
51Liberty588-49.3−1.3
52North Carolina586-78.1−2.1
53Houston584-85.1−1.1
54South Florida577-68.3−1.3
55Arkansas State578-58.00.0
56Texas State578-59.4−1.4
57Syracuse5710-37.3+2.7
58Maryland564-86.5−2.5
59Duke559-46.4+2.6
60Vanderbilt557-65.2+1.8
61Boise State5412-28.2+3.8
62Mississippi State542-104.9−2.9
63Washington546-76.3−0.3
64Virginia545-75.0+0.1
65Western Kentucky548-68.7−0.7
66Arizona State5311-35.2+5.8
67UTSA537-68.3−1.3
68Louisiana5210-48.6+1.4
69Toledo528-58.5−0.5
70Washington State528-57.4+0.6
71Utah State514-87.0−3.0
72Fresno State516-78.0−2.0
73UAB513-96.7−3.7
74UNLV5011-37.8+3.2
75Cincinnati505-75.2−0.2
76Rutgers507-65.7+1.3
77Northern Illinois508-57.4+0.6
78Northwestern494-84.5−0.5
79Pittsburgh497-66.1+0.9
80Rice494-86.7−2.7
81Bowling Green497-67.3−0.3
82Minnesota488-55.1+2.9
83Western Michigan466-77.5−1.5
84Illinois4610-35.0+5.0
85Coastal Carolina456-77.0−1.0
86UConn459-47.0+2.0
87Stanford453-94.3−1.3
88Georgia State443-95.8−2.8
89South Alabama447-66.5+0.6
90Tulane439-56.8+2.2
91BYU4311-24.5+6.5
92Purdue431-114.0−3.0
93Marshall4310-36.4+3.6
94Jacksonville State439-57.9+1.1
95Colorado State418-57.0+1.0
96Miami (OH)419-57.1+1.9
97San Diego State413-96.0−3.0
98Hawai'i405-76.4−1.4
99Charlotte405-75.6−0.6
100Florida Atlantic403-96.2−3.2
101James Madison409-46.7+2.3
102Wake Forest394-84.1−0.1
103Georgia Southern398-56.5+1.6
104Tulsa393-96.1−3.1
105Sam Houston3710-35.9+4.1
106Wyoming373-95.7−2.7
107Florida International344-86.4−2.4
108Massachusetts332-105.2−3.2
109Troy334-84.7−0.7
110North Texas336-75.6+0.4
111Old Dominion325-73.8+1.2
112Oregon State325-74.7+0.3
113Central Michigan304-85.7−1.7
114Nevada303-105.2−2.2
115Southern Miss301-114.7−3.6
116Middle Tennessee303-95.1−2.1
117Louisiana Tech295-86.0−1.0
118New Mexico295-74.8+0.2
119Ohio2911-36.4+4.6
120UTEP293-95.2−2.2
121Akron284-84.0+0.0
122East Carolina278-55.4+2.6
123Temple273-94.1−1.1
124Army2612-25.2+6.8
125Eastern Michigan265-75.3−0.3
126Missouri State248-48.6−0.6
127Kent State240-124.5−4.5
128Navy2310-34.7+5.3
129Air Force235-74.4+0.6
130San José State237-65.0+1.9
131New Mexico State223-93.7−0.7
132Ball State223-93.4−0.4
133Buffalo229-44.5+4.5
134UL Monroe175-72.2+2.8
135Delaware169-28.2+0.8
136Kennesaw State152-102.4−0.4
How the index works

Each player gets a talent score from what was known before the season: last season's production and efficiency, adjusted for the level of his team, plus his recruiting rating while he is young. Transfers bring their production with them. A model trained on every FBS game since 2021 learns how much each position group is worth.

The model never sees the coach or last season's record, so wins above or below expected measure what a staff does with its roster. Past seasons are scored by a model that did not train on them. In one season, about half of the gap is luck in close games; over several seasons, the coach's share shows.

Service academies get an adjustment because their rosters have few rated recruits. BYU's rosters, with many players back from missions, are also harder to rate.