TransferPortl

Roster Talent Index

How much talent each FBS roster held before the 2025 season,from last season's production, transfers and recruits. The index is a roster's chance to beat an average FBS roster on a neutral field. Expected wins apply it to the real schedule, so wins above or below expected show which coaches get more or less out of their roster.

Most wins above talent

  1. BYU12-2, 4.8 exp +7.3
  2. Indiana16-0, 9.4 exp +6.6
  3. Old Dominion10-3, 5.1 exp +4.9
  4. Vanderbilt10-3, 5.5 exp +4.5
  5. Ole Miss13-2, 8.5 exp +4.5

Most wins below talent

  1. Massachusetts0-12, 5.4 exp −5.4
  2. Colorado State2-10, 7.4 exp −5.4
  3. San José State3-9, 7.8 exp −4.8
  4. Colorado3-9, 7.7 exp −4.7
  5. Oklahoma State1-11, 5.7 exp −4.7

2025 FBS Rosters

RkTeamIndexRecordExp. W+/−
1Penn State887-610.7−3.7
2Alabama8711-410.4+0.6
3Texas A&M8711-28.9+2.1
4Notre Dame8610-29.7+0.3
5LSU867-69.5−2.5
6Texas8510-38.8+1.2
7Georgia8512-29.9+2.1
8Florida844-87.0−3.0
9Tennessee848-59.0−1.0
10Miami8313-310.5+2.5
11Ohio State8212-210.0+2.0
12Auburn805-77.3−2.3
13Oklahoma8010-37.6+2.4
14Clemson807-69.1−2.1
15Oregon8013-210.0+3.0
16Baylor795-77.5−2.5
17Missouri788-58.3−0.3
18Texas Tech7812-210.3+1.6
19South Carolina784-86.4−2.4
20Indiana7716-09.4+6.6
21Arizona State768-58.2−0.2
22Louisville769-48.3+0.7
23USC759-48.5+0.5
24Ole Miss7513-28.5+4.5
25Michigan749-48.4+0.6
26Florida State745-77.0−2.0
27Colorado723-97.7−4.7
28Wisconsin724-86.5−2.5
29Georgia Tech719-48.0+1.0
30SMU709-48.2+0.8
31TCU709-47.7+1.4
32Mississippi State685-86.3−1.3
33Rutgers685-77.3−2.3
34Arkansas682-105.3−3.3
35Washington669-47.5+1.5
36Minnesota658-57.9+0.1
37Nebraska657-68.1−1.1
38Virginia Tech643-96.7−3.7
39Kentucky645-75.4−0.4
40Houston6310-36.7+3.3
41Kansas State636-67.1−1.1
42Pittsburgh628-57.1+0.9
43Illinois619-47.0+2.0
44Cincinnati607-67.3−0.3
45Arizona609-47.1+1.9
46Utah5911-26.9+4.1
47NC State598-56.3+1.7
48North Carolina594-86.6−2.6
49Boise State599-59.3−0.3
50Navy5811-28.1+2.9
51Virginia5811-37.5+3.5
52Wake Forest589-47.0+2.0
53Iowa State588-46.5+1.5
54Duke589-57.1+1.9
55Iowa579-45.8+3.2
56Vanderbilt5710-35.5+4.5
57Tulane5711-39.0+2.0
58West Virginia564-86.1−2.1
59Stanford544-84.7−0.7
60UCF545-76.1−1.1
61Oklahoma State541-115.7−4.7
62UConn549-48.9+0.1
63UTSA537-67.1−0.1
64North Texas5312-29.2+2.8
65Toledo538-59.2−1.2
66James Madison5312-28.3+3.7
67Boston College522-105.1−3.1
68California527-66.9+0.1
69South Florida529-47.3+1.7
70Syracuse523-94.2−1.2
71Michigan State524-85.0−1.1
72Georgia Southern517-68.2−1.2
73Southern Miss517-68.1−1.1
74UCLA513-95.2−2.2
75Colorado State502-107.4−5.4
76Oregon State502-106.3−4.3
77Purdue502-104.5−2.5
78East Carolina509-46.9+2.1
79Kansas505-75.0+0.1
80Texas State497-68.1−1.1
81Memphis498-57.0+1.0
82Army497-66.1+0.9
83San José State483-97.8−4.8
84Liberty474-88.1−4.1
85Coastal Carolina466-76.9−0.9
86Maryland464-84.9−0.9
87Northwestern457-64.7+2.3
88Arkansas State447-66.5+0.5
89Fresno State449-46.6+2.4
90UAB444-85.5−1.6
91BYU4412-24.8+7.3
92Buffalo435-77.6−2.6
93Western Kentucky439-47.6+1.4
94Tulsa424-85.5−1.5
95Georgia State411-115.6−4.6
96UNLV4110-47.5+2.5
97Florida International417-67.3−0.3
98Hawai'i419-46.1+2.9
99Washington State417-65.2+1.8
100UL Monroe393-95.6−2.6
101Middle Tennessee393-96.8−3.8
102Utah State396-75.5+0.5
103Florida Atlantic394-85.0−1.0
104South Alabama394-84.9−0.9
105Charlotte371-114.6−3.6
106Louisiana376-76.5−0.5
107Temple375-74.9+0.1
108Kennesaw State3610-47.3+2.7
109Louisiana Tech358-56.5+1.4
110Ohio359-46.4+2.6
111App State355-85.8−0.8
112Nevada353-95.2−2.2
113New Mexico349-45.0+4.0
114Old Dominion3410-35.1+4.9
115Air Force324-85.1−1.1
116Miami (OH)327-76.7+0.3
117Western Michigan3210-46.2+3.8
118Akron315-75.7−0.7
119UTEP312-106.4−4.4
120Wyoming314-84.6−0.6
121New Mexico State304-85.7−1.7
122San Diego State299-45.3+3.7
123Northern Illinois283-95.4−2.4
124Troy288-65.7+2.3
125Rice265-83.9+1.1
126Massachusetts260-125.4−5.4
127Ball State264-84.9−0.9
128Eastern Michigan264-85.0−1.0
129Jacksonville State249-55.8+3.2
130Sam Houston242-104.0−2.0
131Central Michigan237-64.9+2.1
132Marshall225-74.3+0.7
133Bowling Green224-84.2−0.2
134Kent State215-73.8+1.3
135Missouri State207-63.1+3.9
136Delaware207-63.2+3.8
How the index works

Each player gets a talent score from what was known before the season: last season's production and efficiency, adjusted for the level of his team, plus his recruiting rating while he is young. Transfers bring their production with them. A model trained on every FBS game since 2021 learns how much each position group is worth.

The model never sees the coach or last season's record, so wins above or below expected measure what a staff does with its roster. Past seasons are scored by a model that did not train on them. In one season, about half of the gap is luck in close games; over several seasons, the coach's share shows.

Service academies get an adjustment because their rosters have few rated recruits. BYU's rosters, with many players back from missions, are also harder to rate.